Free preview · About this book
Deny Me Watch Me Leave Chapter 1
This chapter runs about 6,057 characters and is one of 2 free chapters on this site.
Reading settings
In the deafening, alcohol-soaked roar of our ten-year college reunion, someone suddenly tossed out a question about the ones that got away.
When the question landed on my husband, Steven, the noise in the room seemed to dial back. His gaze floated right past me, weightless, before finally anchoring on the woman sitting beside him: Judy.
"It was Judy."
He didn’t shout it. His voice was quiet, but it dropped like a heavy stone into a perfectly still lake. The ripples hit everyone in the room.
Judy clearly hadn’t anticipated this. Her manicured hand flew to her mouth, her eyes widening in genuine, breathless shock.
"Then... the letter I slipped into your backpack sophomore year," she asked, her voice trembling with a perfectly calibrated dose of grievance. "Why didn't you ever respond?"
Steven froze, his brows knitting together in confusion. "Weren't you dating Braden back then?"
And just like that, over the rim of half-empty cocktail glasses, an eight-year-old misunderstanding unspooled.
It turned out, Judy had slipped her love letter into the wrong black backpack. That one careless mistake was the only thing that had kept them apart.
The moment the truth settled over them, Judy’s eyes brimmed with cinematic tears. Steven stared at her, his typically guarded face stripped bare, completely awash in shock and profound, tragic regret.
Just then, a voice cut through the heavy air from across the table, dripping with sarcasm. "Come on, nobody is thatunlucky. Makes you wonder if someone noticed that letter and swapped it on purpose, right?"
The air in the private dining room evaporated. Every single pair of eyes snapped away from the star-crossed lovers and aimed directly at me.
Most of the people in this room had no idea that Steven and I had been married for five years. To them, I was just the clueless, delusional ugly duckling who had spent all of college chasing after the campus golden boy.
I turned my head to look at Steven. I was clinging to the very last, fraying thread of hope, praying he would say something. Anything. Just one sentence to clear my name. Just tell them that he was the one who had relentlessly pursued me.
But he didn't say a word.
He just sat there, looking at me with the same complicated, scrutinizing gaze as everyone else.
In that quiet, agonizing space between my heartbeat and my next breath, I reached beneath the table and silently twisted the wedding band I had worn for five years. I told myself what I had been avoiding for half a decade: This circus is finally over.
* * *
The drinks kept flowing.
Judy, crying a delicate, beautiful kind of tears, had scooted her chair flush against Steven’s. They were entirely locked in their own world.
"I can't believe it was all a stupid mix-up," she whispered.
"If I had just written your name on the envelope, you wouldn't have thought... you wouldn't have thought I belonged to someone else."
Steven’s eyes were heavy, dark with a sorrow I hadn't seen in him since his father died. "Nobody could have known."
"That it would end up like this."
Judy was getting emotional, aided by the four martinis she’d downed. Steven—my husband—stayed right by her side. His hand rubbed soothing, gentle circles on her back. He even flagged down a waiter to bring her a glass of iced lemon water to sober her up.
Not once did he look my way.
Around us, our former classmates buzzed like a hive of excited bees.
"God, you can't write this stuff. The ultimate missed connection, finally finding each other almost a decade later."
"So our valedictorian really was in love with the homecoming queen all along."
"Think about it—if they had gotten together back then, they’d probably have kids in grade school by now."
Then, that same venomous voice from earlier chimed in again.
"Yeah, well, if a certain someone hadn't been so shamelessly throwing herself at Steven, maybe they wouldn't have lost all these years."
Their eyes darted toward me, not even trying to hide their disdain.
Under the table, my nails bit so hard into my palms that they broke skin. I pressed my lips into a thin line, refusing to give them a reaction.
After a flurry of whispering, a guy who used to be in our study group slid into the empty chair beside me. He leaned in, his breath reeking of cheap whiskey.
"Come on, Gemma. It was you, wasn't it?" he muttered, a smirk playing on his lips. "Just admit it. You switched the letter so they'd miss their shot."
Ice flooded my veins. I opened my mouth to defend myself, to tell him he was out of his mind, but the crowd didn't wait for my truth.
"I mean, it adds up."
"Everyone knew Steven and Judy were the golden couple waiting to happen. The sexual tension was insane."
"And then there was Gemma. Always lurking. Looking at Steven like a starving dog."
"We all saw it. Every time a late-night lecture ended, she was right there, begging him to walk the track with her. Who knows what kind of dirty tricks she pulled behind the scenes?"
"Swapping a letter is child's play for someone that desperate. Case closed."
They didn't know. They didn't know that Steven and I had been together for eight years, and married for five.
They only remembered that we were always together on campus. And in their narrative, it was because I was pathetic. A toad lusting after a swan.
But they didn't know the reality.
From day one, it was Steven who chased me.
But Steven was intensely private. He hated public displays. He never posted me on his Instagram, never paraded me around. Behind closed doors, he was the one pushing for the relationship, initiating every milestone. But to the outside world, his passive silence made him look like the innocent victim of my obsession.
He was the brilliant, untouchable business major, radiating potential wherever he went.
And I was the girl everyone agreed was punching above her weight.
But that didn't give them the right to humiliate me.
I turned my head and looked dead into the eyes of the guy sitting next to me. My face was a mask of cold stone.
"If you're tired of having a tongue in your mouth," I said, my voice dangerously soft, "I can help you cut it out."