Free preview · About this book
He Broke My Playing Hand Chapter 1
This chapter runs about 6,914 characters and is one of 2 free chapters on this site.
Reading settings
Five years of marriage, and my husband had never sat through a single one of my solos.
Tonight was my debut at Carnegie Hall. It was also my swan song.
I had gone out of my way to mail the ticket to his office, leaving it right on his keyboard with a hand-written sticky note.
Ten minutes before the curtain rose, I peeked through the slit in the heavy velvet drapes, looking down at the third row. At his seat.
Empty.
My phone buzzed in my palm. A notification from Instagram.
It was a photo of a rowdy crowd clinking glasses at a dive bar. Center stage was Roxy, holding her bass guitar, sporting a wild, carefree grin.
The caption read:
"Eighteenth show for my favorite indie band. Perfect attendance record unlocked."
Eighteen shows.
My cello journey had taken me from local recitals to state competitions, from national stages to an invitation to debut at Carnegie Hall.
For every single performance, I had saved him the best seat in the house.
Every single time, it sat empty.
Yet he could memorize every one of Roxy's rehearsal schedules, every grungy venue she played.
He was even the first to comment and congratulate her when she got a new set of guitar strings.
Meanwhile, the day I won the National Gold Medal, his only response was a text:
"Nice. Congrats. Out with clients right now, talk later."
That night, he stayed out until 2:00 AM celebrating Roxy's EP release.
Tonight's final piece was called The Fade Out.
As the final note dissolved into the silence of the hall, I bowed deeply toward that empty seat in the third row.
This is the last time, Daniel, I ever play for you.
* * *
"Charlotte, grab some warm water. Roxy drank too much and her stomach is killing her."
At 2:00 AM, the motion-sensor light in the foyer flickered to life.
Daniel stood in the doorway, supporting a thoroughly drunk, alcohol-soaked Roxy.
Without even kicking off his shoes, he guided her straight to our sofa.
I stood in the middle of the living room, still wearing the black silk performance gown I had just taken off my cello rack.
Roxy leaned heavily into Daniel's chest, her eyes half-lidded.
"Dan... did I ruin your night again?"
"Of course not. Don't talk. Just breathe, okay?"
Daniel looked up at me.
"What are you just standing there for? Get some water."
"The filtered water pitcher is on the counter. The glasses are in the cabinet."
I didn't move.
Daniel's brows furrowed.
"What is wrong with you tonight? Where are your manners?"
Manners. Hospitality.
We had been married for five years. This was my home.
He dragged another woman into our space in the dead of night and lectured me on playing the good hostess.
"Dan, don't yell at her," Roxy murmured, tugging weakly at his sleeve. "Didn't she have that big show tonight? She must be exhausted."
She was the one to bring up the performance.
Daniel finally took a proper look at me, sweeping his eyes over my gown.
"So, your show is over?"
"Yes."
"Was there a crowd?"
"It was alright."
"I told you, classical music is a dying art. Nobody wants to sit through that anymore, but you treat it like gold." He slipped his coat off and draped it over Roxy's shoulders. "Unlike Roxy's gigs. They literally sold out of standing-room-only tickets tonight."
My eyes drifted down to Roxy's wrist.
Something silver was wrapped around it, catching the dim living room light.
A cello string.
Specifically, a custom gut core string imported from Germany. I had waited six months for the set.
Just yesterday, I had opened my case and realized my spare was missing.
"Where did you get that string on your wrist?"
I took two steps forward, staring intently at her hand.
Roxy flinched, pulling her hand back.
Daniel instantly shielded her arm behind his back.
"I took it."
He looked at me, completely unbothered.
"You have a ton of spares lying around in your case, so I grabbed one. Roxy said the thickness looked cool as a braided bracelet. Fit her whole rock aesthetic."
"That is my custom spare."
"It's just a string, Charlotte. I'll buy you ten more tomorrow."
Buy ten more.
He had no idea what it even was. To him, it was just a cheap wire he could replace with a quick online order.
"If that string breaks, my entire acoustic balance is ruined."
"Can you stop being so incredibly dramatic?" Daniel's voice rose. "Roxy had the biggest night of her career. What's wrong with borrowing a string? You're both musicians. Why do you have to be so incredibly petty?"
Both musicians.
I had played since I was five. For twenty years, I hadn't let a single scratch touch my fingers.
Roxy barely knew three basic chords and relied on social media presence and cheap marketing to play dive bars.
And he put us in the same category.
"Oh... I'm so sorry, Charlotte. I didn't know it was that important."
Roxy's eyes welled with tears as she struggled to untie the tight knot around her wrist.
"I'll take it off right now."
She yanked at the stiff gut string, but instead of loosening, it bit deep into her skin, leaving a harsh red mark.
She gasped, wincing.
Daniel immediately grabbed her hand to stop her.
"Stop. You're hurting yourself."
He whipped his head around, glaring at me.
"Are you insane, Charlotte? Tormenting her over a piece of string? How much was it? I'll transfer you double right now."
I watched him hold her close, shielding her like a fragile treasure, and a sudden wave of profound exhaustion washed over me. It was so incredibly pathetic.
A knot of nausea tightened in my stomach.
"Don't bother."
I turned toward the bedroom.
"Charlotte, get back here!" Daniel snapped after me. "You still haven't brought her any water! Where did you get this awful attitude lately?"
"I'm tired."
Without looking back, I stepped inside, shut the door, and turned the lock.
Daniel's muffled, irritated voice leaked through the wood.
"Just ignore her. Always wearing that miserable face, acting like the world owes her something."
"Dan... did I make her mad?"
"She’s always been cold and lifeless. No wonder nobody wants to listen to her play."
No wonder nobody wants to listen.
Sitting in the pitch-black bedroom, I pulled out my phone.
The Carnegie Hall official social media account had posted a recap ten minutes ago.
#CharlotteSymphonyDebutSoldOut
The comments were flooded with praise, calling the finale, The Fade Out, a haunting masterpiece that reached straight into the soul.
But the seat in the dead center of the third row had remained empty from start to finish.
I closed the app and opened my travel program.
I booked a one-way ticket to Berlin for tomorrow afternoon.
Outside the door, the sound of Roxy dry-heaving was followed by the frantic, soothing murmur of Daniel rubbing her back.
"It’s okay, it's okay. Just let it out. I'll grab the mop."
He was a man who wouldn't even pick up a spilled salt shaker.
Yet here he was, in the middle of the night, cleaning up another woman's vomit.
I placed my phone face down on the nightstand.
"You're right," I whispered into the dark, answering his earlier question.
It wasn't worth getting angry over.
Because I was done.