Free preview · About this book
His Love Was Just Hush Money Chapter 1
This chapter runs about 5,461 characters and is one of 2 free chapters on this site.
Reading settings
It was the day my lawyer boyfriend took me home to meet his parents, and the future mother-in-law, Eliza Alistair, decided to share a little anecdote at the dinner table to "break the ice."
“I’d just gotten my license back then,” she said, taking a delicate bite of her artisanal bread. “I snuck out with your father’s prize possession—that vintage Porsche he worships—and I was so nervous, I hit something out on Sycamore Creek Road. I think it was a large dog, maybe? I panicked and just kept driving.”
She chuckled, a light, dismissive sound. “The bumper was totally bashed in. It took forever to fix it in secret. Your father still has no idea!”
She lifted her glass of Meritage, elegantly sipped it. “Thank God that area is so isolated. No traffic cameras, or I would have been in real trouble.”
The knife and fork slipped from my fingers, hitting the porcelain plate with a piercing, metallic shriek.
The model of the vintage car, that specific stretch of suburban road, even the detail of the light drizzle that evening... every single detail slotted perfectly over the memory of the night my brother died.
I looked at Rhys, and his face was a portrait of abject terror. He was deathly pale, his eyes darting away, unable to meet mine.
In that frozen instant, I understood everything.
* * *
The clang of my cutlery against the white china plate was a scream in the otherwise quiet, stately dining room.
Eliza Alistair, Rhys’s mother, froze, the practiced smile on her face dissolving.
She looked at me, a slight frown creasing her brow, her gaze carrying a hint of annoyance at the interruption. “Cassidy, what is it? Not to your taste?”
Rhys's father, Judge Wallace Alistair—a former judge, now semi-retired—also looked up from his newspaper, his eyes, magnified slightly by his reading glasses, sizing me up with cold assessment.
I didn't look at them.
My eyes were locked solely on Rhys.
His hands, resting on the tablecloth, were clenched so tightly his knuckles were white.
A bead of sweat tracked down his temple, and he didn't even dare lift a hand to wipe it away.
“Rhys.”
I spoke the name, the sound of it light, yet laced with a chilling coldness I hadn't known I possessed.
“That road your mother mentioned—is it... Sycamore Creek Road?”
Rhys’s body jerked as if struck.
Eliza’s mask of aristocratic grace finally fractured. She looked at me, eyes narrowed, instantly on guard. “How do you know that?”
I pulled at the corner of my mouth, trying to produce a smile that felt more like a grimace.
“My brother,” I said, the words heavy and deliberate. “He died on that road.”
“Hit by a hit-and-run driver in a vintage car.”
“On a rainy evening, just like you described.”
A deathly silence settled over the room.
The air felt vacuum-sealed, pressing down on my lungs until I could barely breathe.
Eliza’s face cycled through confusion, shock, rising panic, and finally, a sheet-white terror.
The stem of her wine glass snapped, the bowl crashing to the floor. The crimson spill of wine on the pale rug looked horrifyingly like a pool of blood.
“You… you’re talking nonsense!” she shrieked, her voice warped by fear. “Sycamore Creek? I don’t remember any of that!”
“You don’t remember?” I repeated slowly, my gaze drifting to the brand-new, cherry-red sports car parked in their massive driveway. “The car. The license plate ended in 77, didn’t it?”
“Those were the last two numbers my brother managed to whisper before he died.”
Eliza’s lips trembled, unable to form a single word.
Rhys finally moved.
He shot to his feet, grabbing my wrist with a violence that felt like he was trying to crush bone.
“Cass! Calm down! This has to be a misunderstanding! My mother, she—”
“A misunderstanding?” I ripped my arm out of his grasp and stood up.
The sudden, sharp movement sent a jolt of searing pain through the old injury in my right leg. I stumbled, leaning hard against the table for support.
“Rhys, tell me, what is the misunderstanding?”
“Is it that you knew who I was the first day we met, didn’t you?”
“Is it that you approached me, pursued me, and were so kind to me, all because your mother killed my brother, didn’t you?”
“Your love, your tenderness, your thoughtfulness—it was all a lie! It was your form of atonement! Your hush money! Wasn’t it?”
My voice rose with each accusation, each one more desperate than the last. Every word was a blade, first stabbing him, then plunging back into my own heart.
Rhys Alistair!
He looked at me, his mouth opening and closing, his face ashen, utterly unable to deny a single thing.
“Enough!”
The sharp, authoritative command came from Judge Alistair, who had remained silent until now.
He slammed his newspaper onto the table. Standing up, he fixed me with an icy stare.
“Ms. Linnea, you may speak freely in this house, but you cannot speak recklessly.”
“The police classified that incident as an unsolved cold case due to insufficient evidence.”
“To come into my home today, basing your claims on a few baseless speculations, and to loudly ruin my wife and son’s reputation—that is a gross overreach!”
His voice was not loud, but it carried an undeniable, crushing judicial authority.
I looked at the three of them.
A frantic killer.
A guilt-ridden deceiver.
A cold, ruthless accomplice.
Perfect.
What a perfectly intact family.
I suddenly laughed, a hollow sound that ended with tears streaming down my face.
“You’re right. I overreached.”
I wiped my eyes, and slowly, deliberately, limped toward the front door.
“My apologies, Judge Alistair, for the disturbance.”