Free preview · About this book
The Stranger Wearing His Face Chapter 1
This chapter runs about 5,568 characters and is one of 2 free chapters on this site.
Reading settings
It had been entirely too long since the three of us managed to get together for dinner.
I slid into the booth next to my best friend, just like I always did. We were sharing a plate of appetizers when his fork suddenly slipped from his grasp, clattering loudly against the hardwood floor.
"Jesus, Holden! You know I'm left-handed. Why do you always have to sit on my left side?" he snapped, his voice suddenly sharp and loud.
My hand, reaching down to grab the fallen fork, froze mid-air.
He was right. He was left-handed.
But we had a pact. A stupid, private little pact that dictated whenever we ate together, he would use his right hand.
He had once told me that if there ever came a day where he sat next to me and ate with his left hand, it wouldn't really be him.
* * *
It started years ago.
There was this viral thread online analyzing body language, claiming that truly close friends always sit side-by-side at restaurants rather than across from each other. Theo had read it, latched onto it with his usual boyish enthusiasm, and declared that from then on, we were a side-by-side duo.
I had laughed at him, calling him an idiot. "You’re a southpaw, man. If we sit shoulder-to-shoulder, our elbows are gonna be at war the whole meal."
He had paused, chewing his lip before his eyes lit up. "Easy fix. Whenever I eat with you, I’ll only use my right hand."
I gave him three days before he’d crack.
He proved me wrong. For two entire years, every single time we shared a meal, he stubbornly fumbled with his right hand. Occasionally, muscle memory would kick in and his left hand would reach out, but he’d instantly yank it back, rubbing the back of his neck with a sheepish, kid-caught-with-his-hand-in-the-cookie-jar grin.
That was when he said it:
"If you ever catch me eating with my left hand, Holden, you’ll know I’ve been replaced by an alien clone."
He had laughed, but the look in his eyes had been so fiercely earnest that the memory had burned itself into my brain.
Yet right now, the man sitting beside me was comfortably holding a fresh fork in his left hand, flawlessly spearing a piece of food from the center plate.
I stared at that hand for three agonizing seconds before bending down to retrieve the dropped fork.
My own fingers were trembling so violently I could barely grip the metal.
Could the man sitting next to me... not be Theo?
Or was this just some elaborate, morbid joke he was playing on me?
I swallowed the lump in my throat, forcing my head up and pasting on a breezy smile. "My bad, man. I'll move across the table. Don't pop a blood vessel."
I grabbed my drink and slid into the opposite booth.
By the time I settled, Theo's face had returned to normal. He was casually cutting into his steak, launching into a familiar rant about the absolute incompetence of his company’s marketing team. The cadence of his voice, the exaggerated roll of his eyes, the rhythmic tapping of his foot under the table—it was a flawless carbon copy of the man I’d known my whole life.
You’re overworked, I told myself. You’re exhausted and you’re seeing ghosts where there are none.
But the icy dread pooling in my stomach refused to thaw.
A moment later, his girlfriend, Carol, returned from the restroom, sliding effortlessly into the space I had just vacated beside him.
For the next half hour, they fell into the easy, domestic chatter of a long-term couple. Carol rolled her eyes, complaining about her mother hounding them about an engagement ring. Theo chuckled, kissed her temple, and promised they’d tie the knot by Christmas.
It was a picture-perfect, entirely normal Tuesday night.
Until the waiter brought out the fusion tacos, and Theo mindlessly took a massive bite—swallowing a heavy garnish of fresh cilantro.
My heart stalled in my chest.
"Dude, what are you doing?" I choked out.
Carol froze, her fork pausing halfway to her mouth as she looked at him in genuine confusion. "Yeah, babe, what are you doing? You hate cilantro."
Theo blinked, a fleeting shadow of annoyance crossing his face before he masked it with a sigh. "It’s your mom's fault. She sneaks it into everything she cooks for us lately. Guess I just got used to it."
Carol giggled, her cheeks flushing as she leaned in, pressing her face against his shoulder, entirely captivated by his excuse.
I, however, broke out in a cold sweat.
Carol had always thought Theo’s aversion to cilantro was just the picky eating habits of a spoiled rich kid.
But I was the only one who knew the truth: Theo had a severe, life-threatening allergy to it.
Sophomore year of college. The dining hall staff had accidentally mixed cilantro into the salsa. He had taken exactly two bites before his throat started closing up. I was the one who threw him into the passenger seat of my beat-up Honda and blew through three red lights to get him to the ER.
Since that night, he wouldn't let a speck of green near his plate without interrogating the waiter.
You can mimic a person’s laugh. You can memorize their rants. You can even forget the little promises you made.
But you cannot rewrite your body’s biological response.
I sat there for the remainder of the meal, watching him. Waiting for the hives. Waiting for the wheezing.
Nothing. He was perfectly fine. His skin remained clear, his breathing even. He even scooped a little extra pico de gallo onto Carol’s plate.
The cold dread in my stomach crystallized into absolute, terrifying certainty.
The man sitting across from me—laughing with Carol, eating cilantro—was, without a shadow of a doubt, not Theo.
Which left one deafening question echoing in my mind:
Where was my best friend?