Free preview · About this book

The Substitute Chapter 1

This chapter runs about 4,861 characters and is one of 2 free chapters on this site.

Reading settings
Text size
18 px
Line spacing
Paper
Typeface

The summer after graduation, Scott and I finally crossed the line.

Caught up in the heat of the moment, I couldn’t help but cry out, only to hear him whisper a name.

"Luna."

But my name is Rainie. Luna is my twin sister.

I froze, looking up at Scott with uncertainty. "Who did you just call?"

"Rainie," Scott breathed, leaning down to kiss my eyelids, not breaking his rhythm. "You’re distracted. Am I not trying hard enough?"

His movements became more aggressive, shattering my doubts.

Scott was a varsity athlete—star of the track team. He had stamina for days and knew exactly what he was doing.

I trembled, pushing weakly against his chest. "Stop..."

He leaned close to my ear, his voice raspy. "Babe, let’s try being on top."

All night, he tossed me around like a ragdoll. No matter how much I cried or begged for a break, he wouldn't stop. It wasn't until dawn that he finally seemed satisfied and went to the bathroom to shower.

I collapsed on the bed, feeling like my body had been dismantled.

That’s when the phone on the nightstand started blowing up. Ding. Ding. Ding.

It was Scott’s phone. I instinctively glanced over and saw a WeChat notification pop up on the lock screen.

bro congrats on finally popping the cherry last night!

My heart skipped a beat. My hands were shaking as I unlocked his phone.

I opened the group chat Scott had with his teammates, and I froze.

In the middle of the night, Scott had posted a photo of the bloodstained bedsheet.

Below the photo was a stream of messages:

Bro, did you actually do it with Rainie? I thought you were obsessed with Luna?

You guys don't get it. They’re twins. They look the same, bodies are basically the same. Scott’s just using Rainie for target practice. Gotta get some experience so he doesn't hurt Luna when they finally get together.

True that. Luna is Scott’s goddess. Better to break in the spare tire first so he knows how to treat the real deal...

The words were like shrapnel, exploding in my brain and leaving everything blank.

I had imagined a million reasons why Scott chose me. I never imagined this.

Scott was the school’s golden boy. Popular, athletic, dangerous.

I was the quiet one. The nerd. The background character.

We shouldn't have crossed paths, until sophomore year when I had a period accident during gym class. Scott had tied his varsity jacket around my waist.

Since then, there was breakfast on my desk every morning and a handwritten love letter in my locker every day.

First love took root in my heart. But I never understood why Scott chose me.

I once asked him, "Why do you like me?"

He said, "Because it’s you."

My teenage love, the gamble of my entire youth... it was all just a carefully orchestrated "trial run."

I clenched my fingers until my knuckles turned white.

The water in the bathroom stopped. I panicked, closed the app, and put the phone back.

The door opened. Scott walked out with a towel around his waist, water droplets clinging to his abs.

"You're up. Hungry?"

He walked to the bed, asking tenderly, his eyes scanning the red marks on my collarbone.

I looked at him, but all I could hear was the hallucination of him calling out "Luna" last night.

"Not hungry."

Seeing my red eyes, Scott hugged me nervously. His hand slipped under my shirt, clearly wanting to go for round two.

I didn't want him to touch me. I didn't want to be a tool anymore. I pushed him away.

"No. It hurts."

Scott withdrew his hand, looking apologetic as he smoothed my shirt.

"I lost control last night. You rest. I’ll go downstairs and grab breakfast. Need to cool off anyway."

He dressed and left the hotel room.

Staring at the stain on the white sheets, I felt like my soul had been sucked out.

For two years of secret dating, I hid it from teachers, hid it from classmates, and did everything Scott wanted.

He wanted to go to Capital U, so I made Capital U my goal.

He wanted to hold hands under the desk, so I let him while reciting vocabulary.

He wanted to meet behind the bleachers, so I gave him my first kiss.

Now that finals were over, he said he wanted a "rite of passage," so I came to this hotel and gave him my virginity.

I thought this love would last forever. I didn't expect the truth to be a guillotine.

Since he liked Luna all along, then I was done.

I got dressed, walked out of the hotel, found a pharmacy across the street, and awkwardly asked for the morning-after pill.

The clerk looked me up and down, frowned, and slammed a box on the counter.

"Why didn't your boyfriend use protection? This stuff is bad for you, kid."

My face burned.

There were condoms on the hotel nightstand. I had tried to make Scott use one, but he had just bitten my ear, whispering, "Rainie, it doesn't feel good with that on. I’m hurting, babe. Just let me, okay? I promise I’ll pull out."

My softness was rewarded with betrayal.

I paid and thanked the clerk. "Thanks. Just this once."

I would never believe Scott’s lies again.